Alberta Appeal Court keeps $217-million oilpatch cleanup liability case alive
A bankruptcy hearing that could determine whether more than $200 million in oilpatch environmental liabilities wind up on the public dime will have to go back to court.
The Alberta Court of Appeal ruled Friday that the long-running bankruptcy of Sequoia Resources, which involves cleanup costs for thousands of oilpatch facilities, should return to the province's Court of Queen's Bench. Among other errors, the court said the original judge failed to account for the impact unreclaimed facilities have on the value of an energy company.
"End-of-life obligations could be loosely thought of as asbestos in the walls of a house," the Appeal Court justices wrote in their decision.
"It will need to be rectified sooner or later, and someone will have to pay for it ... until then, however, the house is worth less than a similar asbestos-free house."
The case began with a 2016 reorganization of Perpetual Energy, a Calgary-based energy company, that saw many money-losing properties with major environmental liabilities transferred to a now-bankrupt associated company, renamed Sequoia Resources.
That transfer came with a small share in a large number of profitable wells. That share remained with Sequoia for a short time and was quickly sent to a further associated company called Perpetual Operating Company.
Bankruptcy trustee PricewaterhouseCoopers, which brought the lawsuit against Perpetual, argues Sequoia only held the profitable assets long enough for it to pass regulatory review.
Alberta regulators weigh a company's assets against its liabilities before approving licence transfers to ensure companies are able to meet their environmental obligations. Under the rules at the time, Sequoia got full credit for the profitable wells despite owning one per cent of them.
After Sequoia transferred the profitable wells back to Perpetual, it owned mostly liabilities. In 2018, Sequoia declared bankruptcy.
At the time, it held licences for 2,300 wells, almost 200 facilities and nearly 700 pipeline segments. It also owned between 700 and 800 wells where production was stopped but the surface hadn't been restored. Almost two-thirds of Sequoia's holdings were shut in or abandoned.
Court documents put the cost of cleaning up those facilities at $213 million. As well, the company owed another $10 million in unpaid property tax.
PricewaterhouseCoopers claims the transaction that allowed Perpetual to get rid of its unprofitable assets was invalid.
Groups including the Orphan Well Association, an industry-funded body that cleans up wells for which no owner can be found, and Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. intervened in the action in support of PricewaterhouseCoopers.
Perpetual had asked on two occasions for the receivers' lawsuit to be dismissed and was successful both times. Friday's decision is the second Appeal Court ruling tossing those earlier decisions out.
That puts PricewaterhouseCoopers and Perpetual back in Court of Queen's Bench.
Drew Yewchuk of the University of Calgary's Public Interest Law Clinic, who has followed the complicated case, said the rules have changed since Sequoia's bankruptcy. But the case could still have an important impact.
"One of the more interesting questions that might come up is whether an oil and gas company can structure their affairs to get something past the regulator," he said. "The Sequoia and Perpetual transfer was structured in a very bizarre manner."
He called the one-per-cent share Sequoia held in the profitable wells "extremely deceptive."
Neither PricewaterhouseCoopers nor Perpetual Energy responded to a request for comment on the ruling.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 28, 2022.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
RCMP uncovers alleged plot by 2 Montreal men to illegally sell drones, equipment to Libya
The RCMP says it has uncovered a plot by two men in Montreal to sell Chinese drones and military equipment to Libya illegally.
Demonstrators kicked out of Ontario legislature for disruption after failed keffiyeh vote
A group of demonstrators were kicked out of the legislature after a second NDP motion calling for unanimous consent to reverse a ban on the keffiyeh failed to pass.
Tom Mulcair: Park littered with trash after 'pilot project' is perfect symbol of Trudeau governance
Former NDP leader Tom Mulcair says that what's happening now in a trash-littered federal park in Quebec is a perfect metaphor for how the Trudeau government runs things.
Government agrees to US$138.7M settlement over FBI's botching of Larry Nassar assault allegations
The U.S. Justice Department announced a US$138.7 million settlement Tuesday with more than 100 people who accused the FBI of grossly mishandling allegations of sexual assault against Larry Nassar in 2015 and 2016, a critical time gap that allowed the sports doctor to continue to prey on victims before his arrest.
Man wanted in connection with deadly shooting in Toronto tops list of most wanted fugitives in Canada
A 35-year-old man wanted in connection with the murder of Toronto resident 29-year-old Sharmar Powell-Flowers nine months ago has topped the list of the BOLO program’s 25 most wanted fugitives across Canada, police announced Tuesday.
Doctors ask Liberal government to reconsider capital gains tax change
The Canadian Medical Association is asking the federal government to reconsider its proposed changes to capital gains taxation, arguing it will affect doctors' retirement savings.
Keeping these exotic pets is 'cruel' and 'dangerous,' Canadian animal advocates say
Canadian pet owners are finding companionship beyond dogs and cats. Tigers, alligators, scorpions and tarantulas are among some of the exotic pets they are keeping in private homes, which pose risks to public safety and animal welfare, advocates say.
Thieves use stolen forklift to rip cash machine out of U.K. bank
Police in the U.K. are searching for a group of suspects seen on video using a forklift to steal a cash machine from a bank.
'There was a lot of black smoke': Crane operator sounds alarm while trapped during highrise fire in Halifax
A tower crane operator alerted emergency crews after noticing a fire on a construction site in Halifax Tuesday morning.