Alberta government report on supervised consumption 'pseudoscience,' says medical journal
An Alberta government report that influenced safe drug consumption policy is so badly flawed it's harming people and should be withdrawn, says a new study in a prominent medical journal.
The paper, published Monday in the Canadian Journal of Public Health, calls the government's 2019 report into seven supervised consumption sites "pseudo-science." It says the United Conservative-commissioned study is irredeemably flawed by bias against safe consumption sites, in which drug addicts can use illegal substances in a safe and supervised environment.
"It is critical that the report be retracted by the Alberta government and that any of its scientifically trained authors distance themselves immediately from its contents," the new study says. "It is fundamentally methodologically flawed, with a high risk of biases that critically undermine its authors’ assessment of the scientific evidence."
A spokesman for Alberta Health downplayed the report's influence on policy, saying funding was pulled from a Lethbridge site over financial irregularities. Hunter Baril said the government remains willing to fund safe consumption sites.
However, Ginatta Salvalaggio, professor of family medicine at the University of Alberta, said after the report was released in 2020, all plans for new sites in the province were cancelled.
"There's decisions being made on the basis of the data that they present that aren't put up to sufficient scrutiny," she said.
Salvalaggio and her 13 co-authors find three major sources of bias in the government report.
It finds the report presupposed conclusions that consumption sites were harmful and selected evidence to reinforce that.
"The review … explicitly excluded any positive health and social impacts of (consumption sites)," it said. "The report also does not present a balanced account of the information collected throughout the review, emphasizing anecdotes that support the government’s ideological position."
As well, the government study relied on "systematically imprecise measurement," the authors say.
It also failed to examine evidence or studies that contradicted its findings.
"Failure to situate results within existing literature that contradicts a study’s claims increases the risk of confirmation bias when drawing conclusions and undermines the development of evidence-based recommendations," it says.
Scientists rely on peer review to safeguard against bias. Unlike Salvalaggio's paper, the government study was not peer-reviewed.
Salvalaggio said the study wouldn't pass such a test — "not in its current form."
Despite its flaws, Salvalaggio said the study has been influential. It has been cited as far away as a Philadelphia civil case, which resulted in a consumption site not being allowed to open.
"The public needs to understand that this is a dangerous path," she said. "We're already seeing it with other similar reviews out there, for example, safer supply."
The government has also commissioned reports or inquiries into non-health-related fields, including a proposed Alberta pension plan and the impacts of renewable energy development.
Monday's article is not the first to criticize the safe consumption study. A 2021 paper in Harm Reduction Journal by a criminologist said the government study distorted police data and relied heavily on public perception to suggest the sites help increase in crime, despite findings in other peer-reviewed studies.
Baril didn't defend the study, but said the government doesn't oppose safe consumption sites.
"We continue to provide services such as drug consumption sites while also balancing the safety and well-being of communities," he said in an email.
He said the government has funded more than 10,000 new addiction treatment spaces while removing the $40-a-day user fee.
Baril said the government is working with an Edmonton agency to find a new location for a safe consumption site that was closed.
"We remain willing to fund the program."
Meanwhile, Salvalaggio points out 2023 is on track to be the deadliest year for opioid deaths in the province. Newly released numbers put the toll to the end of August at 1,350.
"We're just trucking along at record levels," Salvalaggio said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 7, 2023.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'I screamed in shock and horror': Family faces deadly Vancouver hit-and-run driver during sentencing
The sentencing of the man who pleaded guilty in the deadly hit-and-run in Kitsilano two years ago began on Friday.
Storm brewing in Gulf of Mexico could intensify into a hurricane, threatening Florida
A storm system brewing in the Gulf of Mexico is expected to reach tropical storm status later Saturday, with forecasters warning it could intensify into a hurricane headed to Florida next week.
WATCH LIVE @ 3:30 P.M. Video shows person break into Old Montreal building before fatal fire that killed mother, daughter
The two people who died in a major fire in Old Montreal on Friday were a mother and her seven-year-old daughter, sources told Noovo Info.
Looking for cheap flights for the holidays? Here are some tips to remember
Travelling on a budget can be stressful, but there are ways you can ensure you're getting the best deal on flights as the holiday season approaches.
Frequent drinking of fizzy beverages and fruit juice are linked to an increased risk of stroke: research
New data raises questions about the drinks people consume and the potential risks associated with them, according to researchers at Galway University in Ireland, in partnership with Hamilton’s McMaster University.
OPP charge driver going 175 km/h on Highway 417 in Ottawa
Ontario Provincial Police have laid stunt charges against a driver caught speeding 75 km/h over the speed limit on Highway 417 in Ottawa's west end.
The Menendez brothers case is not the only one that's been affected by a true crime documentary
Being an armchair detective has turned into an American obsession, fueled by an abundance of true-crime content in podcasts and television series. But some of those projects have sparked actual legal developments.
America votes: How the election could impact the Canada-U.S. border
While America's southern border remains a hot button issue on the campaign trail, the result of the U.S. election in November could also impact the northern frontier with Canada, which remains the longest undefended border in the world.
Canadian musician Jacob Hoggard found not guilty of sexual assault
Canadian musician Jacob Hoggard has been found not guilty of sexually assaulting a young woman in northeastern Ontario eight years ago. The former Hedley frontman had pleaded not guilty to sexual assault.