Awkward moment or conscious message? Political experts weigh in on Danielle Smith-Justin Trudeau handshake
An "awkward" attempt at a handshake between Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and the prime minister Tuesday is another example of leaders from the western province hesitating before shaking Justin Trudeau's hand, say political experts.
Smith, in the nation's capital for the First Ministers' Meeting on health care, and Justin Trudeau exchanged brief remarks during a photo opportunity to discuss yet-to-be-tabled legislation addressing the energy transition to a lower carbon future.
The meeting began with Trudeau reaching for a handshake and Smith offering a somewhat hesitant palm. The prime minister smiled, took her hand and held it as Smith presented a clipped smile.
"It was incredibly awkward," said Keith Brownsey, an author and Mount Royal University political scientist.
"When I grew up, if you didn't shake someone's hand who offered a hand and you didn't shake it, you were being extremely rude," he added.
While Smith's terse exchange may not have been planned, Richard Sutherland, a Mount Royal University political scientist, said it still sent a message of hesitancy.
"Keeping your distance politically means sometimes keeping your distance physically when actually confronted with the prime minister," Sutherland said.
"It does send the message that Smith is not altogether comfortable with this moment," he added. "Part of it may simply be recognizing that it is awkward [to meet] someone that you have been really running against politically for the last almost a year.
"It is kind of an interesting moment when you are finally confronted with this person right there in front of you."
In the fall, Smith's first sitting as premier was dominated by the passage of the sovereignty act, legislation giving her government the ability to challenge what it determines to be federal overreach.
Last month, she vowed to "fight" Trudeau's government over the "just transition" framework, which she believes is phasing out the province's oil and gas sector.
In an interview with CTV News Edmonton then, Smith revealed all options were on the table to combat that bill, including using the sovereignty act.
A NEW ALBERTA TRADITION?
To Sutherland, hesitation before a handshake with the prime minister seems to have emerged as an Alberta "tradition" during Trudeau's tenure.
"I think part of it is the optics: It is a long-running aspect of Alberta politics that you can't be too close to the federal government," Sutherland told CTV News Edmonton.
In May 2019, then-premier Jason Kenney also hesitated as Trudeau offered his hand at a meeting on Parliament Hill. A year earlier, during Trudeau's visit to Edmonton, Premier Rachel Notley also took a moment before ultimately accepting a handshake at the photo opportunity.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Alberta Premier Rachel Notley meet in Edmonton Alta, on Wednesday September 5, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Both Kenney and Notley ultimately shook the prime minister's hand.
While Quebec's Francois Legault may have tensely accepted the gesture, Brownsey couldn't think of another time when a premier outside of Alberta recently pulled a similar stunt.
"In the 1980s, even after contentious negotiations over the constitution, contentious negotiations over the national energy program, Alberta Premier Peter Lougheed had the good sense and the manners to shake Pierre Trudeau's hand," Brownsey said.
"They even toasted the agreements to which they came to. You don't see those kinds of signals today in Alberta."
Pre-Trudeau, Sutherland said Alberta premiers were always willing to show cordiality with the prime minister.
"[Ralph] Klein, although he certainly had a troubled relationship with Ottawa at times, he probably wouldn't have made such a show of this," Sutherland said.
Overtly using handshakes as visual campaign symbolism or to play to a politician's base is more of a recent development, especially as the tone between Ottawa and Alberta has become sharper, he said.
"Running against Ottawa is a tried and true technique for premiers across Canada," Sutherland added. "Alberta has pushed that a little bit more than most."
"Certainly, Kenney and Smith's continuous tradition has been that Ottawa has been the problem for Alberta, personified by Justin Trudeau," he said. "So it becomes much more personal than Klein and Chretien back in the day."
In an era where negative attack ads and social media posts are widely used, the shakedowns could be a way to limit how political opponents or groups can use those moments, says Chaldeans Mensah, a MacEwan University political science professor.
"This behaviour could be interpreted as the leaders wanting to maintain political distance from an unpopular political figure in their home province," Mensah said.
"My sense is that Alberta leaders are wary of being portrayed as being too close to the prime minister, even with an innocuous act as a handshake," he added.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau offers his hand to Alberta Premier Jason Kenney in his office on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, May 2, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
'DOESN'T DO ALBERTA ANY GOOD'
On Tuesday, the federal government proposed a health transfer increase to Canada's provinces and territories of $196.1 billion over the next 10 years to help improve health-care systems.
Neither Trudeau nor the premiers planned to walk out of Tuesday's "working meeting" with deals in hand.
Each provincial and territorial government will now develop "action plans" describing what the dollars will go toward. Further discussions between the premiers are expected in the coming days before the final funding agreement is ironed out.
- PM Trudeau presents premiers $196B health-care funding deal, with $46B in new funding over the next decade
When asked if Smith's shakedown was foreshadowing of the province's stance on the federal health-care transfer increase, both Brownsey and Sutherland said the gesture was more likely contained to sending a message to the premier's political base.
For Brownsey, the move "doesn't do Alberta any good."
"It just isolates and embarrasses Alberta," he said, adding it shows a "weak" relationship with the prime minister.
"I don't think Smith would tend to hold out just on her own for a better in this case simply because the possibility of walking away from more federal funding probably isn't a real vote winner, no matter who your base is, " Sutherland said.
"I don't think enough Albertans would want to say no to that just to prove a point."
With files from CTV News.ca's Rachel Aiello and CTV News Edmonton's Sean Amato
Edmonton Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canada makes amendments to foreign homebuyers ban – here's what they look like
Months after Canada's ban on foreign homebuyers took effect on Jan. 1, the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation has made several amendments to the legislation allowing non-Canadians to purchase residential properties in certain circumstances.
Spending to increase economic capacity is fiscally responsible, Freeland says in post-budget defence
Defending her latest federal budget, Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland said spending that increases economic capacity is fiscally responsible.
What is the grocery rebate in federal budget 2023? Key questions, answered
To help offset rising living expenses, the Government of Canada has introduced a one-time grocery rebate for low- and modest-income Canadians. Here is what we know about the rebate.
Victim of Vancouver stabbing had asked man not to vape near toddler, says grieving mom
The family of a 37-year-old man who was stabbed to death in Vancouver last weekend says he was attacked after asking someone not to vape near his young daughter.
Odds and ends: Here are some law changes Liberals plan to put in the budget bill
The 2023 federal budget released this week includes a series of affordability measures, tax changes, and major spends on health care and the clean economy. But, tucked into the 255-page document are a series of smaller items you may have missed.
opinion | Don Martin's sorry-to-be-cynical prediction on the federal budget
The only thing most Canadians will remember about the budget this time next week is how the booze tax increase was reduced to two per cent from six, writes Don Martin in a column for CTVNews.ca.
RCMP interviewing Canadians held in detention camps in Syria: sources
CTV News has learned that RCMP officers are currently in northeast Syria, interviewing Canadians held in detention camps in order to bring them back to Canada. The three Mounties have so far interviewed only Canadian women in Al-Roj camp.
Actress Melissa Joan Hart describes helping children flee campus after Nashville school shooting
Actress Melissa Joan Hart says she was near Nashville's Covenant School soon after Monday's deadly shooting of six people, including three children, and helped some students get away from the scene.
Frustration, anticipation mark industry response to budget's flight delay fixes
The federal government has air travel on its radar after laying out plans in its budget to speed up airport security screening and reduce flight delays, but industry and advocates remain skeptical.
Online video between Danielle Smith and Artur Pawlowski raises questions over interference
In an online video, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is heard speaking with outspoken Calgary pastor Artur Pawlowski, creating questions about her influence on Alberta court cases.
Calgary organization teaches young adults important job skills by fixing bikes
The GAP employability program is for young adults 18 to 24 years old and develops their confidence and life skills through bike education classes and trips.
Will Calgary host UFC 289 in June? Speculation grows on social media
It looks as if there will be a lot of mayhem afoot in the Saddledome this summer.
Saskatoon police release video of 3 people placing 'large container' in dumpster where body was found
Saskatoon Police Service is asking for the public’s help in identifying three individuals they believe are connected to a suspicious death.
Dog that attacked five-year-old Saskatoon boy involved in three other attacks
CTV News has learned a dog that attacked a five-year-old boy last week had been declared dangerous in February 2021, but the city had lost track of the owner a year ago.
Sask. woman regains access to hacked Facebook account
An online business owner in Outlook has regained access to her company’s hacked Facebook page after five months of struggling to get Facebook owner Meta to help resolve the issue.
Evan Bray retiring as Chief of Regina Police Service after 28 years with RPS
Regina's Chief of Police Evan Bray has announced his retirement from policing, but said he plans to pursue other opportunities in the future.
Regina police watching for highly potent 'tranq dope' in local drug seizures
Police in Regina are on the lookout for xylazine, a dangerous animal tranquilizer spreading into Canada's illegal opioid supply.
Saskatchewan to spend $6 million for some hip and knee surgeries in Calgary
The Saskatchewan government is set to spend up to $6 million to send patients to Calgary for hip and knee surgeries.
N.S. mass shooting inquiry report must deliver 'clear commentary': family lawyer
A lawyer who represents Nova Scotia mass shooting victims' families said in an interview they are hoping "for clear commentary on what things went wrong and what things ought to have been done better or differently."
Cold front to sweep mix of snow, rain across the Maritimes Thursday
A low-pressure system moving north of the St. Lawrence River valley will sweep a cold front across the Maritimes on Thursday.
How Portapique residents past and present are dealing with reminders of the 2020 mass shooting
The eve of the release of the final report from the inquiry into Nova Scotia’s 2020 mass shooting is a reminder for residents of Portapique of their small community’s traumatic past.
Toronto police officer accused of failing to properly investigate woman's 'repeated pleas' for help before her murder
A Toronto police officer is facing disciplinary charges after he allegedly failed to 'conduct a sufficient investigation' into a woman's 'repeated pleas' for help with an ex-boyfriend that she had come to fear, just days prior to her murder.
'What motivates someone to do this?' Meat left in Mississauga, Ont. parks in apparent attempts to feed wild animals
Large amounts of meat are being left in public parks across Mississauga in an apparent attempt to feed wild animals and officials say that they are growing increasingly concerned about the practice.
A rare weather phenomenon strikes southern Ontario again
Thundersnow has struck southern Ontario for a second time this month.
Bill 15: Quebec tables legislation to overhaul health system
The CAQ government has unveiled its long-promised plan to improve Quebec's public health network. Tabled at the Quebec legislature Wednesday by Health Minister Christian Dubé, Bill 15 promises a major shakeup.
'I lost a brother': Funeral held for teen who died in Old Montreal fire
Almost two weeks after his death, a funeral was held in Laval Wednesday for a teenager who died in the fire in Old Montreal.
Man who allegedly killed Quebec police officer had long history of violence, mental health issues: court docs
The man who allegedly killed a Quebec provincial police (SQ) officer on Monday had a long history of violence detailed in court documents. Sgt. Maureen Breau was fatally stabbed while trying to arrest a man on accusations of uttering threats in Louiseville near Trois-Rivieres. Two other officers then shot and killed the man.
LRT | Stage 2 of Ottawa LRT faces further delay
The long-awaited southern extension to Ottawa's light rail network is facing a further delay, a city committee heard Wednesday.
WEATHER | Cold front could bring brief burst of heavy snow Wednesday
Environment Canada says a sharp cold front is expected to move through eastern Ontario Wednesday, which could bring a blast of heavy snow.
Meet Zedd! CHEO's new therapeutic clown
CHEO introduced its new therapeutic clown to patients and the public on Wednesday. Zedd takes over for Mollypenny, who retired last year.
Ont. municipal election candidate suing city after names left off ballot
A retired political science professor says he was “stunned” by the way the Cambridge municipal election unfolded.
‘My face was white with shock’: Cambridge father wins $1 million from Lotto 6/49
A 56-year-old Cambridge father has won $1 million from the Lotto 6/49 Gold Ball Draw.
ION train service impacted by weather
Grand River Transit (GRT) said ION trains are not running between Mill Station and Fairway Station due to weather.
BREAKING | Robert Steven Wright found guilty in Renee Sweeney murder
CTV News has learned the jury in the Robert Steven Wright has found him guilty of second-degree murder in the stabbing death of Renee Sweeney in Sudbury on Jan. 27, 1998.
B.C. man pleads guilty to northern Ont. shooting, Crown drops attempted murder charge
A man who admitted to shooting up a home in Greater Sudbury in 2020 over a drug theft pled guilty Wednesday to reduced charges.
Driver caught travelling 200km/hr on major Ontario highway
A 20-year-old has been charged with careless driving after travelling double the speed limit on a major Ontario highway.
Manitobans should prepare for a gas price hike according to an expert
Come the weekend, Manitobans will be paying more for gas and the price could climb even higher in the coming weeks and months according to a gas expert.
Brandon pauses city plan open houses over 'inappropriate and unsafe behaviour'
The City of Brandon has paused its public consultation on its 30-year plan for the city due to 'inappropriate and unsafe behaviour' from some residents.
Death in Main Street hotel room now a homicide; victim identified
Winnipeg police are now treating the suspicious death of a 33-year-old man in a Main Street hotel as a homicide.
'She was a force against ableism': Tributes pour in after sudden death of former Paralympian Arley McNeney
B.C.-born former Paralympian Arley McNeney died suddenly last week, her family revealed Tuesday.
Autopsy confirms missing Kamloops woman was victim of homicide, police say
An autopsy has confirmed that a woman reported missing in Kamloops earlier this month was the victim of a homicide, according to an update from authorities.
Rabbit rescue society warns Vancouver's feral population is about to boom, unless the city steps in
Cities across B.C.’s Lower Mainland should be putting plans in place to prevent feral rabbit populations from exploding, one animal rescue society warns.
IIO investigating after man driving construction vehicle shot, seriously injured by police in Duncan, B.C.
A man was taken to hospital with serious injuries following a police shooting in Duncan, B.C., on Tuesday evening.
Police investigating 'targeted' attempted arson at home in Saanich
Police are investigating what they believe was a targeted arson attack at a home north of Victoria.
B.C. parents win battle to put son's Indigenous name on his birth certificate
After 13 months of fighting, the parents of a Campbell River, B.C., boy have received a birth certificate that accurately reflects the spelling of his name.