Edmonton real estate agent escapes lifetime ban, still faces $21K fine and licence cancellation
A RECA hearing panel fined Ali Merchant $21,000 and suspended him for a year after finding he breached the Real Estate Act on several occasions.
EDMONTON -- A former Edmonton real estate agent has escaped a lifetime ban but still must pay a $21,000 fine and re-apply for his real estate licence in October after a Real Estate Council of Alberta appeal panel ruling.
Mehboob Ali Merchant admitted to several breaches of the Real Estate Act that occurred between 2011 and 2019, according to an Oct. 21 RECA written decision.
A RECA hearing panel found Merchant leased a condo without permission, mishandled a commission, and withheld documents from investigators.
- Lifetime ban sought for real estate agent suspended 1 year over breaches
- Panel upholds $21K fine, suspension for Edmonton real estate agent who admitted to fraud
“The Industry Member committed multiple breaches that were criminal in nature and involved intentional deception for the purposes of enriching himself,” Merchant’s admission of conduct reads as contained in the RECA decision.
“The theft, fraud and identity fraud were all committed intentionally, with full knowledge that he was deceiving his victims,” the RECA hearing panel summary reads.
Merchant appealed the discipline, seeking lighter penalties, arguing the wrong section of the Real Estate Act had been applied. RECA's executive director counter-appealed, and sought a lifetime ban against him.
“Had it not been for these errors, the Hearing Panel would have imposed the proper sanction of licence cancellation and lifetime licensing prohibition.”
Today, RECA appeal panel sided with Merchant, upholding his initial sanctions and dismissing the appeal for a lifetime ban.
Merchant's licence was cancelled by RECA effective Oct. 17, 2019. He can reapply for a new licence on Oct. 18, 2020 and must also pay $1,500 in costs.
CTV News has reached out to Merchant for comment but has yet to hear back.
'THIS IS THEFT'
Merchant’s case stretches back to February of 2011, when he received $20,000 from his client to be paid as commission on the condo’s purchase contract.
The RECA decision states that he instead deposited those trust funds into his own bank account.
“This breach was a crime of knowing deception and proven dishonesty,” argued RECA’s case presenter. “He never gave it to his brokerage. This is theft.”
Merchant cited his industry inexperience at the time and called the deposit “a clerical oversight” which he said “can simply be dealt with administratively.”
“I did pay all applicable fees charged by my brokerage, and thereby, did not commit any theft,” Merchant argued as per the RECA decision.
LEASE DEAL CONFUSION
Four years later, the same condo (and owner) were at the centre of another incident involving Merchant in January of 2015.
According to the RECA decision, Merchant attempted to enter into a lease with the condo owner on the understanding he was acting on behalf of his brokerage.
In actuality, the tenant was a corporation Merchant had registered to appear to be his brokerage.
“He did this for the purpose of personally profiting and thereby committed identity fraud,” the decision reads.
While admitting his actions were reckless, Merchant argued the corporation was registered by his wife to handle her private real estate portfolio.
“It was not my corporation and I have never had any positions or rights to this corporation.”
RENTED WITHOUT PERMISSION
The next month, Merchant rented out the condo to a tenant, but did so without the owner’s permission and without telling that tenant he wasn’t authorized to lease the property, according to the RECA decision.
“This cost [the tenant] money because she had to move early and unexpectedly. This cost [the owner] money because she was deprived of the lawful use of her own property.”
The decision notes Merchant offered to pay the owner back but also that it was less than what he collected and the gesture came only after he was under investigation.
“[Merchant] unlawfully collected rent from [the tenant], which he kept for himself. This is fraud.”
Merchant argued he never told the tenant that he owned the condo but that he didn’t share with her the written agreement he had with the condo’s owner
“This was reckless on my part but not fraudulent.”
In April of 2015, the owner filed a formal complaint with RECA, sparking an investigation in which Merchant was accused of withholding evidence.
“RECA investigators asked Mr. Merchant multiple times to provide a copy of the lease with GC and copies of all correspondence in regard to that lease,” reads the decision.
“He intentionally withheld these documents.”
Merchant stated the documents were not in his possession when asked for them and that they were later recovered from the tenant by investigators.
Merchant told CTV News fraud charges against him had been dropped.
He worked under the name Ali Merchant in Edmonton with the Century 21 Platinum Realty company but is no longer listed on its website.