Indigenous groups stand firm with child welfare law before Supreme Court
Some Indigenous nations say they are prepared to continue enforcing their jurisdiction over child welfare if Canada's top court sides with Quebec in a landmark constitutional case.
Bill C-92, or An Act Respecting First Nations, Metis and Inuit Children Youth and Families, became law in June 2019. It affirms that Indigenous nations have sole authority of their children and establishes minimum standards in caring for them.
Quebec put the act to the constitutional test at its Court of Appeal, which ruled in 2022 that parts of the act are out of the federal government's scope to legislate. Ottawa appealed that decision, and the matter is now before the Supreme Court of Canada.
Peguis First Nation in Manitoba, with 11,000 members, is one of six nations to have formed its own child and family law, and it did it through ceremony -- not "under" the law, C-92, said the in-house counsel for the community's Child and Family Services.
“The federal government didn’t give us anything, they didn’t allow us anything,” said Earl Stevenson.
“What we’ve done through our own self-determination and our inherent rights, we’ve created this law."
Stevenson said, in one instance, two infants were being transferred from a provincial CFS office in Winnipeg to Peguis. The CFS office in Winnipeg was initially seeking a permanent order keeping them from their parents.
He said that Peguis declined, as it avoids permanent orders.
The matter went to a King's Bench judge who granted a three-month temporary order under Peguis's new law, Stevenson said. He said this marked the first time that court approved such an order aligning with Indigenous law.
Stevenson said apprehension should be the last resort for the First Nation, and the agency wants to avoid children going through that traumatic experience.
He also said there have been no child protection matters in the last five months for Peguis, the first time that’s ever happened.
Peguis also plans to develop its own court system but isn’t quite there yet, he said.
“For now, we’ve granted the King’s Bench in Manitoba, and the provincial court in Peguis, concurrent jurisdiction to hear our matters.”
Carrier Sekani Family Services, which serves 11 nations in north-central British Columbia, had its own family law model when C-92 emerged, said executive director Mary Teegee.
But she stressed that C-92 is not solely about drafting laws.
“You actually have to start building the capacity in your own agency to provide the services to the community, and in the community," she said.
Teegee, who also represents B.C. on the board of the First Nations Child and Family Caring Society, said she always knew communities had inherent jurisdiction but lacked the resources to "breathe life" into their own laws.
She said she also represents B.C. on the board of the First Nations Child and Family Caring Society, noted the absence of funding provisions in C-92.
Both Teegee and Stevenson said funding mechanisms will rely on co-ordination agreements involving federal and provincial governments and Indigenous government entities.
Andrea Sandmaier, the president-elect of Otipemisiwak Métis Government in Alberta, said it was exciting when C-92 became law.
“To reclaim our children is something very important to our citizens."
Sandmaier said her office developed a family reunification program in Edmonton with plans for another in Bonnyville, Alta.
She says there have been no challenges in this process yet.
"We actually just sent a letter to give notice to the minister of Indigenous Services Canada and the minister of child and family services in Alberta of our intent to exercise our jurisdiction under C-92 law, and we are looking forward.”
The United States Supreme Court upheld legislation this summer affirming that Native American families have priority in the adoption of Native American children. Stevenson said the "positive treatment" in the U.S. bodes well north of the border for the C-92 reference case.
If the act is not upheld by Canada's Supreme Court, Stevenson said "we’re not going to disappear," referencing Aboriginal rights protected under Section 35 of the Constitution.
Theresa Stenlund, Region 1 councillor at Métis Nation of Ontario, said her organization would also continue to push forward.
"We've been given direction by the citizens and by our communities to move forward and continue to push to look after our children."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 28, 2023.
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, the diplomat with the thick glasses and gravelly voice who dominated foreign policy as the United States extricated itself from Vietnam and broke down barriers with China, died Wednesday, his consulting firm said. He was 100.
A number of doctors are facing scrutiny for publicizing their opinions on the Israel-Hamas war. Critics say expressing their political views could impact patient care, while others say that it is being used as an excuse for censorship.
Compared to the peak pandemic years of 2020 and 2021, Canada experienced an uptick in prescription drug shortages in 2022 that Health Canada says has continued throughout 2023.
Owen Grace has spent the last 20 years sharing his childhood hobby, Lego, through an exhibit he calls, 'Bricks by the Sea.'
The Canadian government has reached a deal with Google over the Online News Act that will see the tech giant pay $100 million annually to publishers, and continue to allow access to Canadian news content on its platform. This comes after Google had threatened to block news on its platform when the contentious new rules come into effect next month.
'We wish we could've reached that kid earlier,' says online educator about boy's suicide after apparent sextortion
The chat may seem innocuous at first. The victims, often young men or boys, start communicating with someone posing as a young girl, typically on the popular social media platforms Instagram and Snapchat. But with sextortion, which occurs when people are blackmailed for money or sexual favours, 'sextorters' convince them to share a sexual photo or video.
Ten Israeli women and children and four Thai nationals held captive in Gaza were freed by Hamas, and Israel followed with the release of a group of Palestinian prisoners Thursday. It was the latest exchange of hostages for prisoners under a temporary ceasefire in the Gaza war. Two Russian-Israeli women were also freed by Hamas in a separate release.
Some provinces are moving to HPV tests as the primary mode of cervical cancer screening, and others are close behind, an expert says.
With speculation rising that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau will follow his father's footsteps in the snow to a pre-election resignation, political columnist Don Martin focuses on one Liberal cabinet minister who's emerging as leadership material -- and who stands out as a fresh-faced contrast to the often 'angry and abrasive' leader of the Conservatives.
Alberta's police watchdog has taken over a review of CPS use of force during arrests at a demonstration in support of the people of Gaza on November 19.
Alberta Health Services is warning the public about a lab-confirmed case of measles in the Calgary area, adding that the public may have been exposed.
Hockey history was made on the Siksika Nation Wednesday night.
After two days of discussing the 2024-2025 budget, some councillors are concerned about the lack of progress made.
The Saskatchewan Roughriders have selected Toronto Argonauts defensive coordinator Corey Mace as the team's next head coach, according to reports from TSN's Farhan Lalji.
A Saskatoon man is celebrating a remarkable milestone this week as he turns 104-years-old. With a life that has spanned over ten decades, Nick Kazuska is still going strong.
To address wait times, the provincial government announced they will be sending women who need urgent breast cancer tests to Calgary.
A pro-Palestinian protest in Regina sought to disrupt rail traffic in the city’s centre on Wednesday.
Police in Halifax say they are investigating after human remains were found in the Armdale area Tuesday.
A man had to be rescued from a Moncton dumpster that was emptied into a garbage truck Wednesday morning.
The Nova Scotia civil servant overseeing delivery of 200 small heated shelters for the homeless is pointing to the need for community "buy in" and proper access to services such as washrooms before they are installed.
A 15-year-old boy is facing several charges for his alleged involvement in an armed carjacking in North York.
Woman may have been pushed out of moving vehicle in 'dynamic' incident in Etobicoke that left cop injured: police
Toronto police are investigating a "dynamic event" that unfolded in Etobicoke Wednesday that saw a woman reportedly being pushed out of a moving vehicle and an officer seriously injured during the arrest of a suspected hit-and-run driver.
A Toronto police officer shot an advancing 35-year-old man holding a knife in a Scarborough home last August to protect himself from an attack, the province’s police watchdog has found.
Montreal police are investigating after the suspicious death of a man in the city's west end Wednesday evening.
A man in his 60s was rushed to hospital in critical condition Wednesday night after a fire at a home in Montreal's east end.
Quebec seems ready to back down from its plan to double tuition prices for university students outside of the province in exchange for more ambitious francization programs at English-speaking universities.
Ottawa Fire Services are recognizing hospital staff after a fire broke out at the Ottawa Hospital General Campus last month.
As Ottawans brace themselves to find out if the canal will reopen this year, El Niño might have other plans.
Have you decorated your home for Christmas yet? Many are going all-out this year, fully embracing the season, with a 'maximalist Christmas.'
There's been a gradual increase in building permits for backyard homes in Kitchener. But these tiny homes aren't necessarily small.
Police are investigating two separate incidents where a driver approached a female youth in Kitchener and offered her a ride.
Guelph’s 2024 property tax hike won’t be as high as initially proposed.
A 65-year-old from Greater Sudbury was killed in a single-vehicle crash just after midnight Tuesday on Highway 69.
After four years as top cop, North Bay Police Chief Scott Tod is retiring, the local police board announced Wednesday.
Manitoba RCMP is searching for a suspect who set fire to a home in West St. Paul with young children inside.
True North’s real estate wing is asking for a six-month extension on a plan to buy and redevelop Portage Place Mall.
'We need to address the violent crime in Manitoba': Province's homicide rate nearly triple national average
Grim new statistics show Manitoba once again has the highest homicide rate per capita in all of Canada.
Crown counsel argued Wednesday that the woman who stabbed another woman in a B.C. courtroom should face between 15 and 18 years behind bars.
The ongoing saga of Surrey policing has yet another chapter. Last Friday, the Surrey Police Union filed court documents alleging harassment and bullying by Surrey RCMP members.
An Abbotsford MLA is comparing conditions inside Abbotsford Regional Hospital to something you might find in a “third world country.”
B.C.'s attorney general recently made comments in the media and online that "risk undermining the public’s confidence in the criminal justice system," according to a letter published by the British Columbia Branch of the Canadian Bar Association.
Climate activists to unveil 'massive' ice sculpture at B.C. legislature to coincide with COP28 summit
Climate activists in Victoria say they will deliver a "massive" ice sculpture to the B.C. legislature Thursday as part of a protest against the province's liquefied natural gas industry.
Ukraine has now been at war with Russia for more than 640 days. “It’s so stressful,” said Anna Terbiak, a Grade 11 student in the west of Ukraine.