Kenney's office denies 'poisoned work environment' in legal dispute with former legislature staffer
The premier's office in Alberta is denying a former employee was subjected to a "poisoned work environment," and is asking for her lawsuit to be dismissed, according to a statement of defence obtained by CTV News.
The document, filed in an Edmonton court on Monday by lawyer Vicki Giles, says plaintiff Ariella Kimmel was fired without cause because the minister she was assigned to no longer wanted to work with her.
It says Doug Schweitzer asked for Kimmel to be replaced as his chief of staff "on several occasions," because he wanted his former chief of staff back.
Schweitzer refused to elaborate on why when asked by CTV News Edmonton on Thursday, saying he couldn't comment because of the court proceedings.
The statement claims there was "no other role was available" for Kimmel, so she was terminated.
Kimmel has claimed she witnessed sexual harrasment, was subject to verbal abuse, and was fired for raising those concerns to officials in Jason Kenney's office.
The statement of defence does not name Kenney at all, and says Kimmel's lawsuit is technically against the Queen, as represented by the premier's chief of staff.
Kimmel said she witnessed excessive drinking in the legislature involving a former minister.
When she confronted Devin Dreeshen about that, she alleges he "angrily confronted" her about the situation and "aggressively yelled at her" until she was in tears.
"The plaintiff felt shaken and scared during this encounter," her lawsuit says.
Dreeshen resigned from cabinet in November, but remained a UCP MLA.
“I accept that my personal conduct with regards to alcohol has become an issue for the government as a whole,” Dreeshen wrote at the time.
In the defence statement, Giles argued that if the incident did happen, it wasn't work related.
"If the Alleged Incident did occur, it was a disagreement between the Plaintiff and Mr. Dreeshen, with whom the Plaintiff was admittedly involved in a personal relationship. Further, the Plaintiff was not acting within the scope of her employment at the time the Alleged Incident occurred," the document said.
In her lawsuit, Kimmel is seeking $199,233 (the balance she claims is owed to her for her term of employment), $100,000 in moral damages and $100,000 in punitive damages.
She is also seeking a declaration that she was wrongfully terminated along with costs of the legal action.
Giles argues Kimmel's employment contract allowed the premier's office to terminate her without cause, and she is only entitled to $29,541 because of that agreement.
The defence said Kimmel found another job and the premier's office did not cause her "mental distress, embarrassment or reputational harm."
Giles said the legislature has policies in place to protect employees, and respect in the workplace training was made mandatory.
"At all material times the Defendant maintained clear workplace policies and procedures regarding harassment and respect in the workplace," the statement said.
Kimmel also alleged that Ivan Bernardo, who was the principal secretary to then-Minister of Health Tyler Shandro, make a sexually inappropriate comment to one of her staff members
"If the Alleged Comment was made, the incident was resolved to the satisfaction of the individual to whom the comment was directed insofar as is known to the Defendant," the statement said.
Giles also alleges that Kimmel "engaged in inappropriate and disrespectful behaviour towards scheduling staff, the Director of Talent, and other members of the Premier's Office Staff and department officials," during her employment.
Kimmel's lawyer, Kathryn Marshall, said the government's response is an example of why some people are scared to make workplace misconduct claims.
"I'm very disappointed that the government has chosen to continue their pattern of retaliatory conduct towards my client by maligning her character," Marshall said.
"The assertions in the statement of defence about my client's character are completely false."
Marshall said the lawsuit will continue and she declined to comment on how her client is feeling about the government's response.
"I do look forward to cross-examining Premier Jason Kenney who is someone who has very key information about the matter in this court proceeding," Marshall said.
None of the allegations in the statement of claim have been tested in court. A court date for the lawsuit has not been set.
With files from CTV News Edmonton's Chelan Skulski
Edmonton Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Trudeau decries 'fringe' views of some in trucker convoy, as police prepare for its arrival in Ottawa
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is decrying the 'fringe' views among some of those who are supporting the trucker convoy making its way to Parliament Hill to protest COVID-19 vaccine mandates and other policies they feel infringe on their freedoms.
'So many angry people': Experts say online conversation around trucker convoy veering into dangerous territory
As a growing group of truckers and supporters make their way to Ottawa in a protest against vaccine mandates, experts say the rhetoric online concerning the convoy is getting increasingly worrisome.
The Public Health Agency of Canada says it has detected more than 50 cases of a new Omicron subvariant known as BA.2. The subvariant is widely considered 'stealthier' than the original version of Omicron because some of its genetic traits make it harder to detect.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced on Wednesday the extension of Operation UNIFIER for three years, and the deployment of 60 more troops to Ukraine in the coming days.
CTV News in Ukraine | 'If I'm called, I will go': Ukrainian reservist and former Voice contestant ready to fight Russian threat
CTV's Omar Sachedina speaks to a Ukrainian reservist and former contestant on Ukraine's version of 'The Voice' about the looming threat of war with Russia.
Homicide investigators have been called to a Richmond, B.C., duplex after a shooting that left four people dead.
Police say a series of stabbings in the downtown core last month have been determined to be hate-motivated and targeting vulnerable Calgarians.
Mounties say autopsies have begun as they try to identify the four people who were found dead in a frigid Manitoba blizzard near the United States border.
Spotify is removing the discography of Canadian rocker Neil Young after he demanded it be taken off the platform over concerns with its connection to vaccine misinformation and comedian Joe Rogan’s podcast.
'People are fed up': convoy of trucks converges on Ottawa as police prepare for thousands on Parliament Hill
A convoy of hundreds of fed-up Canadian truckers are driving cross-country, heading for the nation’s capital to deliver a message that's raising millions of dollars from donors around the world.
Work is underway converting a vacant Seventh Avenue Calgary office tower into 82 units of affordable and specialized housing.
Last week, Nicolle Atherton and her son parked their cars outside their northeast Calgary home like they do every evening. The road was basically dry, but it was a cold night. When she went to her car the next morning, she couldn’t believe what she saw.
Nathaniel Carrier has pleaded guilty to first degree murder in connection to the death of his son and second degree murder in connection to the deaths of his parents.
Saskatchewan reported 1,194 new COVID-19 cases on Wednesday, along with six more deaths, however active cases are down again.
A popular Riversdale restaurant says it's putting a "pause" on its operations.
Saskatchewan’s premier is hinting some COVID-19 restrictions could soon be lifted, saying current measures may have run their course.
Whether its memories of attending them, or the recent discoveries of unmarked graves at the sites of former residential schools, many people have been mentally strained by the former schools.
Sylvester Ukabam, a former Regina doctor accused of sexually assaulting five female patients, continued to deny allegations made against him from the witness stand on Wednesday morning.
Premier Tim Houston said Nova Scotia is extending its current provincewide COVID-19 public health restrictions until Feb. 14 in an attempt to limit the spread of the virus.
An area of low pressure originating off the coastline of Florida will merge with a cold front on Friday. The resulting storm will rapidly strengthen into a nor’easter, which will move north to impact the Maritimes Saturday into Sunday.
The Halifax Regional Police are on the scene of a sudden death at a hotel in the city.
An Ontario woman who says she was offered a free doorbell by a salesperson said she wishes she didn't then sign a 15-year contract for a furnace that will cost her $12,748.
Drivers are being warned to expect significant traffic delays on major highways from Thursday to Saturday as the 'Freedom Convoy' of truckers enters Ontario.
Toronto police have arrested two men who allegedly impersonated officers and conducted traffic stops in Scarborough late last month.
Three COVID-19 patients who were unvaccinated or partially vaccinated have received double lung transplants at a Montreal hospital after their lungs were irreversibly damaged by the disease. One patient was a 49-year-old mother of five.
Since the start of the pandemic, Quebec has issued tickets totaling more than $45 million for public health violations, but only a fraction of them have actually been paid so far, according to data provided to CTV News.
The Universite de Montreal announced Wednesday that it's rolling back the fifth-wave rule that requires lecturers to wear a mask, even for three-hour lectures, as long as they stay two metres from others.
Officials are urging people to avoid downtown Ottawa this weekend with a cross-country ‘Freedom Convoy’ of truckers expected to arrive at Parliament Hill.
"They keep telling us the risk is low but it's been mostly based on the fact that the ground is frozen," said Agnes Warda with the Glens Community Association.
Ottawa's top doctor says Ottawa Public Health will not wait for schools to report absenteeism rates above 30 per cent before investigating a possible COVID-19 outbreak in schools.
Officials reported four new deaths related to COVID-19 on Wednesday, along with a dip in hospitalizations.
'There are some calls that stick with you': A dramatic increase in mental health disability claims amongst first responders
First responders, like paramedics, firefighters, and police officers say they often deal with mental health challenges.
If the start of 2022 has felt particularly frigid to you, your instincts are correct.
While the region is not out of the woods with regard to the rapid spread of the Omicron variant, Algoma's medical officer of health says there is reason for optimism.
The union representing teachers says the Near North District School Board had enough N95 masks for the first eight days of in-person learning after school resumed, but has now run out.
Sault Ste. Marie Police are alerting the public to expect significant traffic delays as a truck convoy makes its way into Sault Ste. Marie on Thursday.
Manitoba's top doctor says hospitalization rates remain high but are stable – though it is too early to tell where the province is in the pandemic's current wave.
A U.S. border patrol agent says a group of people from India attempting to cross the Canada-U.S. border faced blizzard conditions and freezing temperatures during an 11-hour-long trek that left four people dead.
Dr. Brent Roussin, Manitoba’s chief public health officer said the province is continuing to see a significant amount of spread of COVID-19.
BREAKING | 21 deaths included in latest B.C. COVID-19 update, highest single-day total in over a year
Twenty-one more COVID-19 related deaths were reported in B.C. on Wednesday, the highest single-day total the province has added to its death toll since December 2020.
The B.C. government is under pressure to reconsider a change that means some people on disability are getting less money – despite the government's vow to support them through the pandemic.
Health officials have confirmed a "very small number" of COVID-19 cases involving a new Omicron subvariant have been found in British Columbia.
Five deaths related to COVID-19 were confirmed in the Vancouver Island region Wednesday, according to the B.C. Ministry of Health.
British Columbia's forest watchdog has identified four key areas where the management of forestry practices can negatively affect water and outlines potential opportunities for the province to improve regulations.
The British Columbia government says it will distribute up to 250,000 rapid COVID-19 antigen tests to provincially funded child-care providers.