Alberta privacy commissioner raises concerns over 2 government bills
Alberta's information and privacy commissioner says she has big concerns – including fuzzy definitions and insufficient guardrails – in two bills now being debated in the house.
The bills aim to amend existing access to information and privacy rules and are touted by Premier Danielle Smith’s government as being the strictest privacy regulations in Canada.
But commissioner Diane McLeod says, to the contrary, the government would be creating legislative holes if the bills are approved.
McLeod outlined her concerns and suggested changes in letters sent Wednesday to the sponsors of the bills: Technology Minister Nate Glubish and Service Alberta Minister Dale Nally.
Glubish's bill would create a separate act for the protection of privacy while Nally’s bill proposes changes to freedom of information rules.
McLeod noted Glubish’s bill would allow the personal information of a minor to be shared without that minor's permission if doing so was deemed to be in the youth's best interest.
McLeod noted that the bill isn't clear on who would be responsible for determining the best interests of minors, nor is it clear what best interest means.
"If disclosure is truly 'in the best interests of a minor' then it should be with consent,” McLeod wrote.
The commissioner's letter also says Glubish's changes don't account for privacy risks when government bodies use "automated systems" to collect and make decisions around personal data.
McLeod wrote that it isn't clear what an automated system even refers to or if artificial intelligence would be involved. She says privacy guardrails are therefore critical.
When it comes to changes put forward by Nally to Alberta's freedom of information rules, "there are many grounds for concern," McLeod wrote.
She wrote that the proposed changes give the government more power to avoid disclosing information to the public by including in the exempted correspondence “virtually all communication between political staff and (members of cabinet).”
Nally defended this change Wednesday, saying that such electronic communication should be confidential as freedom of information "is about access to government documents, not about political conversation."
McLeod's letter says she is also concerned about broad disclosure exemptions for government records relating to labour relations and "workplace investigations," both of which the bill doesn't provide a definition for. The letter also says the bill appears to exempt the disclosure of data kept in government databases.
"In my view, this amendment takes access rights a step back, not forward,” she wrote.
Glubish and Nally told reporters they will review McLeod's concerns and recommendations over the coming days. Glubish also said that the government gave McLeod "unprecedented access" to the development of the legislation, but in a statement Wednesday, McLeod said her office didn't see the finished bills until they were introduced in the legislature.
Both bills have passed first reading in the assembly and will need to be read and debated three more times before receiving royal assent.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 20, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
A police photographer recounts the harrowing day of the Polytechnique massacre
Montreal crime scene photographer Harold Rosenberg witnessed a lot of horror over his thirty years on the job, though nothing of the magnitude of what he captured with his lens at the Polytechnique on December 6, 1989. He described the day of the Montreal massacre to CTV Quebec Bureau Chief Genevieve Beauchemin.
NDP's Singh forces debate on $250 cheques for more Canadians; Conservatives cut it short
With the fate of the federal government's promised $250 cheques for 18.7 million workers hanging in the balance, the NDP forced a debate Friday on a motion pushing for the prime minister to expand eligibility. The conversation was cut short, though, by Conservative MPs' interventions.
DEVELOPING Police believe gunman who killed UnitedHealthcare CEO has left New York City
The gunman who killed the CEO of the largest U.S. health insurer may have fled the city on a bus, New York City police officials told CNN on Friday.
Purolator, UPS pause shipments from couriers amid Canada Post strike
Purolator and UPS have paused shipments from some courier companies as they try to work through a deluge of deliveries brought on by the Canada Post strike.
Northern Ontario man sentenced for killing his dog
WARNING: This article contains graphic details of animal abuse which may be upsetting to some readers. A 40-year-old northern Ontario man is avoiding prison after pleading guilty to killing his dog earlier this year.
Sask. father who kept daughter from mom to prevent COVID-19 vaccine free from additional prison time
Michael Gordon Jackson, the Saskatchewan father who withheld his then seven-year-old daughter from her mom for nearly 100 days to prevent the girl from getting a COVID-19 vaccine, was handed a 12-month prison sentence and 200 days probation on Friday, but credited with time served.
Health Canada says daily cannabis use hasn't changed much since legalization
Health Canada says daily cannabis use has remained stable since it was legalized in 2018.
Ticketmaster hidden fees settlement credits expected in 2025 following class-action lawsuit by Regina lawyer
A longstanding lawsuit against Ticketmaster is nearing its end, with a judge expected to approve the more than $6 million dollar settlement before the end of the year.
What is still being delivered? What to know about the Canada Post strike
With Canada Post workers on strike, many individuals and businesses are facing the challenge of sending and receiving mail. Here are the answers to some of Canadians’ most-asked questions.