'One of those gosh darn decisions': $50M ask for Valley Zoo upgrades slashed in half by council
The Edmonton Valley Zoo will receive only half of the requested money from city council to renew existing infrastructure and meet licensing requirements.
As council continues to deliberate the 2023-26 budget cycle, a series of proposals were brought forward to reduce capital expenditures Friday.
By a slim 7-6 vote, council decided to slash the approximately $50 million needed by the zoo to initiate the next phase of the Nature's Wild Backyard expansion by half.
Initially, Coun. Jo-Anne Wright pitched scrapping the entire project altogether. An amendment to give the zoo $25 million to simply meet critical infrastructure requirements was then put forward by Coun. Michael Janz.
"I do see the educational value of the zoo," Wright said. "But I think at this time, this is something that needs to be deferred. Not necessarily cancelled, but just put off to a date when we are maybe in a better economic situation."
Roger Jevne, zoo spokesperson, told council "several" animal habitats do not meet Canadian Association of Zoos and Aquariums (CAZA) standards. The Nature's Wild Backyard plan included replacing aging infrastructure with a new expansion.
"We have some that we've got an exemption on because they were being replaced by Nature's Wild Backyard," he explained.
"So we would have to go back and determine what our strategy would be for those enclosures and those species and come up with a new plan, which could be having to rehome those species or trying to retrofit or expand their current exhibits."
- Transit security, recreation, Valley Zoo investment among budget asks at Edmonton council hearing
- Zoo money, zoo problems: Edmonton's facility needs $11M to repair 'major deficiencies'
The project, first proposed in 2005, has already been delayed twice. Back then, the zoo anticipated it would need $5 million.
It was then divided into two phases to spread the work and cost over time. The first phase of Nature's Wild Backyard, which opened the Red Panda Habitat and Urban Farm, was completed in 2017.
A different budget ask, which has yet to be considered by council, is also seeking $10.9 million to repair enclosures for several other animals, including Lucy the elephant, birds of prey and zebras.
"Certainly, this is one of those gosh darn decisions," Janz said. "This reduction would still preserve many of those critical pieces we need."
Adam Laughlin, deputy city manager of integrated infrastructure services, cautioned councillors that if the shovel-ready project is scaled back, until there is a full project reassessment, it is not known if there would be surefire cost savings.
"Because we would be actually investing in existing infrastructure, not sort of an investment in the plans for Nature's Wild Backyard, there's a lot of uncertainties," Laughlin added. "Because we are on the fly identifying a budget amount to carry out work that would be required without doing a design."
Jevne echoed those concerns, saying that some utilities installed during phase one were built temporarily in anticipation of a full replacement during the project's second phase. Leaving them without upgrades would pose a risk to the zoo, he added.
Before the vote, Coun. Sarah Hamilton urged the consideration of the reputational risk of losing CAZA accreditation to both the city and the zoo. She also said zoos are an important way of conserving species as the world faces biodiversity loss.
"When you stand before an animal and understand in your lifetime, they may not exist anymore, that turns your audience into advocates," Hamilton said as she fought back tears.
Coun. Ashley Salvador disagreed, saying the answer to solving animal habitat loss was nature-based solutions and concrete climate action. In her view, the return on investment for zoo upgrades was low.
Both her and Coun. Erin Rutherford said city council should have a larger discussion in the new year about what the future strategy for the zoo should look like.
"The true elephant in the room right now is that the zoo is already giving us a bad reputation in some of the animals we've brought in," Rutherford said.
"The fact that we haven't updated our master plan since 2005, and I think the world has evolved in the way it thinks [about zoos]."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING 'The best that we can be': Indigenous judge and TRC chair Murray Sinclair dies at 73
Murray Sinclair, who was born when Indigenous people did not yet have the right to vote, grew up to become one of the most decorated and influential people to work in Indigenous justice and advocacy.
India's Modi, Canada's Trudeau condemn violence at Hindu temple near Toronto
The prime ministers of India and Canada condemned violence that broke out on Sunday at a Hindu temple near Toronto at a time of escalating diplomatic tensions between the two countries.
She was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes about a year ago. Here's how her condition was reversed
A year ago, Lorraine O'Quinn was coping with stress, chronic illness and Type 2 diabetes. Then she discovered a health program that she says changed her life.
Frustration over Mideast war in America's largest Arab-majority city may push some away from Democrats
As an ongoing part of Omar on the Road: America Decides 2024, CTV National News visited the University of Michigan-Dearborn campus to talk to Arab-American students about why they’re feeling left out of the Democrats’ tent.
3 people arrested after incident during protest at Hindu temple in Brampton, Ont.: Peel police
Peel Regional Police say three people are in custody as they continue to investigate an incident during a demonstration at a Hindu temple in Brampton on Sunday.
Judge rules against Alberta casino, dinner theatre operator
An application to stay a receivership order of Mayfield Investments Ltd., a company that owns multiple businesses in Alberta including the Camrose Resort and Casino, Medicine Hat Lodge and Calgary's Stage West Dinner Theatre, has been denied by the court.
Ikea will pay 6 million euros to East German prisoners forced to build their furniture in landmark move
Furniture giant Ikea has agreed to pay 6 million euros (US$6.5 million) towards a government fund compensating victims of forced labour under Germany's communist dictatorship, in a move campaigners hope will pressure other companies to follow.
Police arrest Netanyahu aide as opponents accuse him of leaking intelligence to thwart Gaza ceasefire and hostage deal
Israeli police have arrested a top aide to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu over allegedly leaking classified information to foreign media.
Candlelight vigil held outside Halifax Walmart where employee was found dead
Hundreds of mourners took part in a candlelight vigil Sunday night for a young woman who was found dead at a Halifax Walmart last month.