Doctors fear Alberta bill of rights changes may discourage vaccination uptake
Adriana LaGrange insists changes to the province's bill of rights will solidify personal freedoms around bodily autonomy, but Alberta's health minister wouldn't provide an example of when that right was violated, instead urging people to wait to see the legislation.
It comes as doctors worry the new legislation could discourage more Albertans from getting a vaccine.
In a video posted online Tuesday, Premier Danielle Smith announced changes to Alberta's bill of rights she says will protect Albertans' right to refuse a vaccination or other medical treatment.
The changes will "reinforce the right of every Albertan to make their own choices regarding medical treatments they receive," Smith said in the video.
LaGrange wouldn't clarify on Wednesday how the province will define who has the freedom to make those medical decisions, instead urging Albertans to wait to "actually see the wording of the bill."
"It will be balanced to make sure we have the ability to function as a society as well and to ensure the safety of all," she told media.
"There is a reasonableness (in) language in there."
Now, a group of doctors with the Edmonton Zone Medical Staff Association is concerned the province is prioritizing protecting Albertans' rights to refuse vaccines over education about vaccine safety.
Dr. Steve Fisher, an emergency room physician at the Royal Alexandra Hospital, told CTV News Edmonton on Wednesday the group wonders where the government's priorities lie.
"Are they supportive of vaccination campaigns?" Fisher said.
"We are concerned about the overall message that sends on the importance of vaccination, and we just want our government and our health minister to be advocates of the best preventive form of health care."
Health law expert Lorian Hardcastle says the broader implications of the bill are not clear.
She said some people worry the bill might reduce the uptake of vaccines across the province and that it might "tie the hands of governments and other decision-makers in a future public health emergency."
Hardcastle, an associate professor in the Faculty of Law at the University of Calgary, says it could prevent employers from requiring vaccines and prevent regulatory colleges from disciplining members who spread misinformation.
"(Or) is this just affirming existing legal rights because people are concerned with what went on during the pandemic and perhaps a nod to anti-vax members of the government space?" Hardcastle told CTV News Edmonton.
Smith said Wednesday in Calgary she campaigned in the 2023 election on ensuring Albertans wouldn't be "forced to take a medical treatment they don't want to take."
She told media the changes to the bill were also informed by a $2-million pandemic review by Preston Manning she ordered to make good on a promise of strengthening Albertans' rights.
"I hope that's how people look at this," Smith said.
"This is me keeping my commitment that I made when I got elected."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Biden and Harris call the Israeli strike killing Hezbollah’s Nasrallah a 'measure of justice'
The Israeli strike that killed Hezbollah's Hassan Nasrallah was a 'measure of justice' for victims of a four-decade 'reign of terror,' U.S. President Joe Biden said Saturday.
At least 52 dead and millions without power after Helene's deadly march across southeastern U.S.
Hurricane Helene caused at least 52 deaths and billions of dollars of destruction across a wide swath of the southeastern U.S. as it raced through, and more than three million customers went into the weekend without any power and for some a continued threat of floods.
LGBTQ2S+ minister Pascale St-Onge to make history with parental leave
Canadian Heritage Minister Pascale St-Onge is set to make history by becoming the first openly lesbian cabinet minister to take parental leave when her wife gives birth in the coming weeks.
SpaceX launches rescue mission for 2 NASA astronauts who are stuck in space until next year
SpaceX launched a rescue mission for the two stuck astronauts at the International Space Station on Saturday, sending up a downsized crew to bring them home but not until next year.
What is open and closed this National Day for Truth and Reconciliation
This Monday, Sept. 30 is the National Day for Truth and Reconciliation (NDTR), a federal statutory holiday and day of remembrance for the Indigenous children who never came home from Canadian residential schools, as well as those who survived them.
They hit it off on vacation but then he went silent. So she decided to pick up the phone
When a few weeks passed and Nana Prempeh still hadn’t heard from the guy she met on vacation, she turned to her friends for advice.
Sima Sistani, who embraced Ozempic, is out as CEO of WeightWatchers
WeightWatchers CEO Sima Sistani, who pushed the company into embracing weight-loss drugs, is leaving the position after a two-and-a-half year stint.
Scientists discover hidden ancient forest on treeless island
Trees haven't grown on the Falkland Islands for thousands of years. But tree trunks and branches preserved in peat suggest the islands were once home to a forest.
Russia invokes its nuclear capacity in a UN speech that's full of bile toward the West
Russia's top diplomat warned Saturday against 'trying to fight to victory with a nuclear power,' delivering a UN General Assembly speech packed with condemnations of what Russia sees as Western machinations in Ukraine and elsewhere — including inside the United Nations itself.