'Not be tolerated': Alberta files formal response to proposed oilsands emissions cap
![Danielle Smith Alberta Premier Danielle Smith addresses a news conference in Ottawa on Monday, Feb.5, 2024.THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2024/2/5/danielle-smith-1-6756908-1707172695242.jpg)
Alberta and two prominent business groups have released formal responses to a proposed federal emissions cap as the province's environment minister was slated to meet with her federal counterpart.
"This cap is not realistic or effective, will not achieve its grandiose emissions targets and will not be tolerated in Alberta," says the province's official response.
Federal Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault was to meet with Alberta Environment and Protected Areas Minister Rebecca Schulz Monday.
Guilbeault has proposed to cap emissions across the energy sector at between 35 to 38 per cent below 2019 greenhouse gas emission levels and companies will be able to purchase credits to allow for flexibility.
Alberta’s concerns were echoed by the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers and the Business Council of Alberta, a big-business lobby group.
All three say an emissions cap would achieve the opposite of its intended goals.
"There are other existing and proposed policies that will more effectively contribute to Canada's long-term emission reduction goals," wrote the association.
The council said those goals are "best accomplished through a robust and transparent price on carbon."
Alberta's formal response to Ottawa's proposal says the cap would undercut the work that the province has been successfully pursuing "for decades" to reduce emissions.
It says oilsands production has already risen above the forecasts that were used to establish the proposed 100-megatonne limit and that the technology needed to bring emissions down enough doesn't yet exist.
The document repeats arguments that Ottawa's plan violates the Constitution.
Alberta is one of the few places in North America with rising greenhouse gas emissions and is by far Canada's largest emitter. The oilsands recently set a production record and remains among the most carbon-intensive oil producers in the world.
Economists agree a production cap may not be the most economically efficient way to meet Canada's Paris climate goals.
University of Alberta energy economist Andrew Leach says targeting the oilsands could mean Canada loses out on the value of the oil produced. Cutting emissions elsewhere could achieve the same climate impact with less cost — a goal that could be achieved with a significant, broad-based carbon tax.
Leach, in an interview, said about 90 per cent of the emissions from agriculture are not priced even though that industry releases about the same amount of carbon as the oilsands.
"You're not going to solve this problem in Canada by going after one sector," he said.
Still, Leach noted Alberta’s argument is also not entirely consistent.
While it has had a carbon price on industrial emissions since 2004, Leach said the province has opposed measures such as clean-fuel standards and electricity grid regulations.
"There's a simultaneous commitment to emissions reduction and opposition to any policy that might reduce emissions,” he said.
Leach added that Alberta's constitutional argument is weaker than its anti-cap position. While the Supreme Court has recently ruled against two federal environmental initiatives, those rulings don't provide much support to Alberta's argument on the emissions cap, he said.
The Court has ruled in the past that Ottawa can regulate greenhouse gases. It's also hard for Alberta to argue the federal government has no jurisdiction over anything that affects production, said Leach — regulation of pipelines being one example.
In an emailed statement, Guilbeault said "Putting a cap on pollution is essential to the long-term competitiveness of the oil and gas sector in a global economy that is advancing towards net-zero emissions by 2050.
"We will continue to consult the sector as we develop our approach. No industry should be allowed unlimited pollution and we hope the Alberta government will see how beneficial and essential this policy is for our environment and our economy.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 5, 2024.
Correction
This is a corrected story. A previous version said Guilbeault had proposed capping oilsands emissions at 100 megatonnes and Premier Danielle Smith used to work for the Business Council of Alberta.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6946231.1719664723!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
WestJet cancels at least 150 flights following mechanics union strike
WestJet says it's cancelled at least 150 flights beginning Saturday after the union maintaining the airline's planes announced it went on strike hours earlier.
Health Canada recalls brand of sunscreen product due to potential fungal contamination
Double check your sunscreen products before lathering up this long weekend, as Health Canada has recalled several lots across the country.
Tenants in 16-floor apartment building in Ottawa's west-end served eviction notices
More than 100 people in Ottawa's west-end are in the process of receiving eviction notices to vacate their 50-year-old apartment building for renovations.
opinion Practical tips for seniors who want to supplement their retirement income
Are you retired and looking for some ideas to help make some extra money? Personal finance contributor Christopher Liew has some tips to help you earn some income in your golden years.
The small French town where Newfoundlanders were heroes
It was a battle ripped from the pages of a storybook: Ten soldiers held off hundreds of German troops to save a small French village in the First World War.
As fall elections loom, are fears for the state of democracy in Canada justified?
Is Canada's democracy truly under threat? Political scientists say while Canadian politics and institutions are facing a myriad of concerns, the situation isn't dire overall.
Ontario woman loses $1,000 deposit in cottage rental scam
For many, the Canada Day long weekend is the official kick off of summer and many families will be spending time at a cottage.
Driver charged with DUI for New York nail salon crash that killed 4 and injured 9
A minivan slammed into a Long Island nail salon Friday, killing four people and injuring 9, a Suffolk County fire official said.
'We need new leadership': Liberal MP writes to caucus, says Justin Trudeau should resign
A sitting Liberal MP has written to the federal caucus to say he thinks Prime Minister Justin Trudeau should resign. 'For the future of our party and for the good of our country we need new leadership and a new direction,' said New Brunswick MP Wayne Long in the brief note.