'Economic blow': Experts warns of US election's potential impact on Canadian economy
University of Calgary economics professor, Trevor Tombe, discusses the upcoming US election and its potential impact on the Canadian economy.
This interview has been edited for clarity and length.
Michael Higgins: Your report raises a red flag about protectionist policies, but is it just Donald Trump who Canadians should be paying attention to?
Trevor Tombe: You're right that both parties have taken a more protectionist stance on a number of policy files and have under successive administrations. Softwood lumber that would have been escalated under President Biden, that's a fight we've been having for quite some time. Or issues around procurement, or the ability of Canadian companies to be involved in some of the new initiatives south of the border through the Inflation Reduction Act, and subsidies for certain climate-related investments in the United States. That's all run of the mill, normal trade tensions between two large economies.
What's new in this campaign south of the border is the proposal from former President Trump to levy an across the board tariff of 10 per cent on everything, and potentially as high as 20 per cent. Depending on when you catch him, he'll cite a higher number than 10. That's something that we haven't seen any credible presidential candidate put forward, and not a policy measure that we've seen the US adopt in a very long time.
MH: The former US ambassador to Canada, Bruce Heyman, told an audience in Calgary recently that a new president imposing tariffs would be one of the most detrimental potential proposals for the Canada-US relationship.
What kind of damage could that do to the Canadian economy?
TT: It's really hard to overstate how significant economic damage from such a measure would be, not just on Canada, but also the United States.
The US and Canada trade is not just where we produce one thing, they produce another, and then we exchange the classic, historical way of thinking about trade. Our two economies are deeply interconnected through supply chains that cross the border back and forth, where parts are made in one part of the country, shipped to another, assembled into some other input that is then shipped back across the border.
Just to illustrate, about 12 cents of every dollar exported from Canada to the United States is actually value that originated in the US, like an input into something else that's shipped back. We have close to $2 trillion in direct investment flowing both ways in terms of this relationship, so if we levy a 10 per cent tariff, that really changes all of the business and investment calculations behind those big supply chains.
And what we do in this report for the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, released just a few days ago, is try and quantify how much of an impact this would have. What we find is that it would shrink Canada's economy by potentially as much as 1.6 per cent, which might not sound like a lot, but that's about $1,100 per person, or about $45 billion in total and just lost economic activity because of lower productivity as a result of this tariff.
The costs in the US are almost as large and so it really would be a big economic blow.
MH: So if you look at it from both sides of the border, where does this register on the radar of Americans? How aware are they of the importance of trade between our two nations?
TT: The US is, of course, a large country with diverse states with economic relationships that vary. Canada is an incredibly important trading partner for the northern states in particular, but 34 of the US states have Canada as their top export destination.
Michigan, for example, trade between it and Canada is equivalent to about 14 per cent of its entire economy, which is more than what British Columbia has in terms of its trade between it and the United States as a share of its economies.
But if you look among some of the southern states, it's much smaller. Nevada, for example, just a little over 1 per cent of its economy is tied to trade with Canada, so there are differences.
But I'd note, interestingly, that many of the kind of Midwestern swing states that are critically important in this year's electoral campaign are disproportionately tied to Canada in terms of their own economic well-being. So an across-the-board tariff would disproportionately harm those states, and Michigan in particular.
MH: Where should this register on the radar of Albertans? The premier certainly had it in her sights as far back as February when she traveled to Washington for meetings with lawmakers on Capitol Hill.
TT: This is very important for manufacturing in Ontario, that shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone, but it's also important for Alberta because the largest export from Canada to the United States is actually energy and the overwhelming majority of that is oil and gas, largely from Alberta.
So a 10 per cent tariff on goods across-the-board, well, that would mean a few things. In part, some of that would be borne by US consumers. Tariffs are largely attacks on those who are doing the importing. So this would mean higher cost to refineries and higher gasoline prices in the Midwest of the US in particular.
But some of the tariff might also be shifted up to producers in Alberta. Taking a haircut, accepting a lower price, if you will, for oil shipped to the US that would lower revenue, lower investment, potentially have employment implications in the sector.
Interestingly for the Government of Alberta, it would also mean lower royalty revenues. If the Alberta price received by producers here falls as a result of the tariff, then so do royalty revenues. So it could potentially be a multi-billion dollar hit to the Government of Alberta.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
W5 INVESTIGATES Ontario woman alleges sexual assault by junior hockey players; details what happened when she called police
The OPP has acknowledged that one of its employees did not follow the organization's policy when an alleged victim of sexual assault called its London detachment earlier this year to report an incident involving eight former junior hockey players.
Trudeau says he has list of Conservatives vulnerable to, or engaged in foreign interference
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has refused to get the security clearance necessary to be briefed on a list of people in his party involved in, or vulnerable to, foreign interference, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told a federal commission of inquiry Wednesday.
Canada Revenue Agency fires 330 employees over CERB claims during pandemic
The Canada Revenue Agency says it has terminated 330 employees for inappropriately receiving the Canada Emergency Response Benefit during the pandemic, giving its final update on an internal review.
What could happen if Trump rejects the U.S. election results
Republican U.S. presidential candidate Donald Trump says that if he does not win the Nov. 5 election, he will cry fraud and not accept the results -- just as he did four years ago when he lost to Democratic President Joe Biden.
This Saskatchewan community had more meth in its wastewater than any Canadian city, study shows
A humble city in Saskatchewan appears to be consuming more methamphetamine than anywhere else in Canada, based on recent Statistics Canada data.
Billions of litres of Canadian milk were discarded in the last 12 years. A new study says it has a massive impact
Researchers say billions of litres of discarded Canadian milk has a massive financial, environmental and nutritional impact.
Indians in Punjab fear dispute with Canada endangers work, study plans
Indians in Punjab, worried that plans to work, study or visit families in Canada will be jeopardized by this week's tit-for-tat expulsions of diplomats over the murder of a Sikh separatist, are urging both governments to reduce the tension.
DND confirms unexploded bombs from Second World War buried in popular Ottawa hiking area
The Department of National Defence confirms unexploded bombs from the Second World War lie buried inside the Mer Bleue Bog, a popular hiking and skiing area in Ottawa’s east end.
WATCH LIVE PM Justin Trudeau testifies at foreign interference inquiry
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is testifying today, for the second time, as part of the federal inquiry into foreign interference.